Test coverage

AI Test Generation: Cover Behavior, Not Just Lines

AI can help draft tests, but useful coverage comes from choosing the right behavior to protect. A test that merely repeats an implementation can pass while the user-facing behavior is wrong. Begin with a clear contract and review the generated assertions.

Choose behavior with a meaningful failure condition

Identify the inputs, observable output, and state transitions that matter to users. Prioritize authorization boundaries, payment handling, destructive actions, and previously reported defects over easy-to-cover utility code.

For each proposed test, explain what real regression would make it fail. If the answer is only that a private helper was renamed or called differently, the test may be too tightly coupled to implementation details.

  • Cover successful behavior and relevant failure behavior.
  • Include empty inputs, boundaries, and invalid values.
  • Test important state transitions, not only initial state.
  • Keep expected results independent from the implementation under test.

Choose the smallest appropriate test level

Use a unit test for isolated business logic, an integration test for interactions between real components, and an end-to-end test for a critical user journey. Not every behavior needs to be tested at every level.

Follow the repository’s existing test runner, setup files, and conventions. Introducing a second framework solely because a generated example uses it increases maintenance without necessarily improving confidence.

Mock boundaries without mocking away the behavior

Replace external services when isolation is necessary, but avoid replacing the very logic the test claims to verify. Assertions should inspect meaningful outputs or effects rather than only counting calls to implementation-specific helpers.

Keep fixtures small and deterministic. Control clocks, random inputs, and network dependencies explicitly so that a failure points to behavior rather than an unstable environment.

  • Do not assert only that a mock returned its configured value.
  • Avoid arbitrary delays as a substitute for awaiting completion.
  • Restore shared state and mocks between tests.
  • Use realistic error responses at external boundaries.

Review generated tests and their actual results

Run the new tests and the relevant existing suite. For a regression fix, establish that the focused test fails against the faulty behavior and passes with the fix when practical.

Treat line coverage as a diagnostic, not the acceptance criterion. The handoff should identify protected behaviors, executed commands, actual results, and important scenarios that remain untested.